socialmedianickGet a quote
All writing
2 minNick Chiarella-Hamblin

Test it before it hits your grid: Trial Reels are the cheapest research you can run

Short answer

Trial Reels show a video to people who don't follow you first, so you can test two or three versions of an opening before anything reaches your followers or your grid.

Most brands treat Instagram like a stage. Film it, edit it, post it, hope. If it flops, it flops in front of every follower you have, on your grid, for good.

Trial Reels turn that round. You test first, in front of people who don't know you yet, and only the winners get a proper post.

Why this matters more than a better idea

I keep seeing the same thing on competent accounts. The idea is fine, the edit is fine, and the video stalls at a few hundred views. Very often it's the first second. If the opening doesn't stop a thumb that's already moving, nothing after it gets tested.

That's a hook problem, and hooks are the one thing you can test cheaply. You don't need a better idea. You need three openings and a way to find out which one works.

How I'd run it

  1. 1Pick one video you were going to post anyway.
  2. 2Shoot three different openings. Different in kind, not in angle. A finished result first. A problem stated in plain words. A contradiction. Same video after that.
  3. 3Post each as a trial. Same caption, same everything else.
  4. 4Compare the start of each one. Which opening held more people past the first few seconds? That's your winner.
  5. 5Post the winner properly, then change one more thing and test again.

The rule is one change at a time. Change the opening and the music and the text together and you've learned nothing, except that something worked.

What to test, in order

  • The opening visual. Frame one. What's actually on screen at 0.5 seconds?
  • The on-screen text. Five words that tell someone what this is and who it's for.
  • The first spoken line. Does it carry a stake, or is it "hi guys"?
  • The sound. Does something land in the first half second?
  • The caption. Does it agree with the video, or fight it?

I go through all five in [the five layers of a hook](/blog/instagram-growth-is-a-hook-problem).

Keep a log

Write down the idea, the one thing you changed, what moved and what you'll change next. Without a log, test and learn is just posting a lot. With one, every trial makes the next post better.

What a trial won't tell you

A trial tells you whether people stopped and stayed. It doesn't tell you why anyone would save or send it. That's the message, and it needs its own test. Holding attention and getting someone to act are different jobs.

Want me to set up a test plan for your account? That's what a [channel audit](/services/channel-audit) starts with: what you're posting now, what's stalling and what to test first.

Key facts

  • A Trial Reel is shown to non-followers first, so a bad opening costs you nothing with the people who already like you.
  • Test one thing per trial. Change the opening and keep the rest of the video the same.
  • The first second decides whether the next thousand people see it, so that is what to test first.
  • A winner earns a proper post. A loser stays off your grid.

Common questions

What is a Trial Reel on Instagram?
A Reel that is shown to people who don't follow you before it goes to your followers. You see how it did first, then decide whether it earns a place on your grid.
What should I test with Trial Reels?
The opening, first. Shoot two or three different first seconds for the same video, post each as a trial, and keep the rest identical. That tells you which opening did the work.
Will a Trial Reel hurt my account if it flops?
It stays away from your followers and your grid, which is the point. A flop is cheap information.

Want this run on your own numbers?

The free performance report applies all of it to your export, in your browser.

Open the tool
Test it before it hits your grid: Trial Reels are the cheapest research you can run — Social Media Nick